Last night's American Idol featured the classic tunes of the good humored yet kinda scary-looking Dolly Parton. Oddly enough, it wasn't Dolly's crimes against fashion that raised eyebrows. Instead, it was Carly Smithson who got picked on for her plain jane and specifically non superstar-like attire. Simon stopped short of ripping her a new one, but he definitely called her out.

Lets face it, looks matter big time -- especially on American Idol. If Carly wants to win, she has to do a better job at looking the part. Watching the performance last night, we thought she looked a little bit like she dressed herself. Do you think Carly's look is OK? Or is she in desperate need of a Miles Siggins makeover?