Karl Lagerfeld Defends Skinny Models - 'No One Wants to See Round Women'
by Katie Hintz-Zambrano (Subscribe to Katie Hintz-Zambrano's posts), Posted Oct 12th 2009 at 2:55PMThis is a post
Filed under: News
Karl Lagerfeld looking a little wide himself -- in the tie and collar area. Photo: Pascal Le Segretain, Getty images
Lagerfeld was interviewed by the German magazine Focus, during which the designer responded to the announcement of best-selling German magazine, Brigitte's commitment to using "ordinary, realistic" women instead of professional models in future fashion spreads, the U.K. newspaper reports.
Lagerfeld, speaking in German, his native tongue, told Focus that Brigitte's plan was "absurd," and that the women complaining about too-skinny models were just fat and jealous.
"These are fat mummies sitting with their bags of crisps in front of the television, saying that thin models are ugly," the Chanel designer tells Focus, going on to say that the fashion industry supports "dreams and illusions, and no one wants to see round women."
According to The Guardian, he also tries to dispel the myth that skinny models have eating disorders.
"It's just as much a cliché as saying that all models take drugs and get drunk at sex orgies," he says. "Ninety percent of them are quite normal, properly proportioned girls with less fat and more muscles, who also eat pizzas and burgers."
Brigitte's editor, Andreas Lebert, sees things differently. On October 5th, he told The Guardian that after years of "fattening up" too-thin models through Photoshop, starting on January 2nd, the magazine will start working with real women only.
"Today's models weigh around 23% less than normal women," Lebert told the paper. "The whole model industry is anorexic. We will show women who have their own identity, the 18-year-old A-level student, the company chairwoman, the musician, the footballer."
Of course, all of this comes on the heels of Ralph Lauren's emaciated ad and, at the opposite extreme, Glamour'scommitment to showing plus-size models and women of more diverse sizes.
So, how do you weigh in on the model controversy? Is Lagerfeld right to defend his runway rails or are Brigitte and Glamour taking steps in the right direction?
Leave a comment below!














"b" 10-12-2009 @ 8:19PM
this idiot just got lucky in life and probably has never got his precious little hands dirty. i myself like a little meat on women
Reply
pinkthenred 10-12-2009 @ 8:27PM
Jealous and fat just because I don't prefer a body type other than what Karl Langerfield finds to be attractive? What this really boils down to is an arrogant man making an arrogant statement. Whoop dee doo, like that has never happened before :)~.
Reply
Jerry 10-12-2009 @ 8:30PM
Why don't fat women open up their own fashoin show? They do not because even they don't want to see fat women walking up and down the aisle.
Reply
sadiemae1214 10-12-2009 @ 8:41PM
Got news for you Jerry, Large size women are now walking the runways and even doing nude photo layouts. They have NO SELF ESTEEM problems and their men love them. Maybe all you've dated is anorexic bimbos with boney butts and no brains.
john 10-12-2009 @ 8:47PM
Jerry what an empty headed ass you are! What passes for beauty nowadays, bones, tattooed titties and piercings don't interest a real man. Someone like you always prefers bony women because their built like boys. Keep it real jer.
LGC 10-13-2009 @ 9:45AM
You're a pig and probably single.
Tammy 10-13-2009 @ 10:01AM
Jerry, I hate to tell you this sweetie (actually, no I don't) but 'big girls' do everything the skinny ones do. I am a 'big girl' and I have been approached to model for several companies. So the reason behind my personal dislike for the waif look has nothing to do with wanting to be like them. My concern is my daughters will become swept up in the 'glamour' of it and want to become these girls. There isn't anything wrong with being thin, however, everyone is built differently and some people (like my girls) have to make themselves sick to look that way. It can cause a bad body image for girls who don't look rail thin.
I am proud of my curves, my husband loves them and I wouldn't want to look any different.
Heather 10-13-2009 @ 10:52AM
Normal weight models (to you, fat women) do have runway shows. Why is it assumed they don't? And normal is still thin. A size 10 is average. When the models top out at 6'......a size 10 is small. Trust me, I'm 6' 2" and wear a size 8 at the moment.....I could stand to gain some weight. To me, plus size would be just that, plus size, size 14 and up, and the model being of varying heights. 6' is not the norm. About 5' 8" is.
Enough ranting. I just wanted to say that plus sizes do get their time on the runway. Maybe not as much as they deserve, but they get it.
dconn4 10-13-2009 @ 9:50AM
Nobody wants to see ugly,gay men modeling either-but that hasn't stopped you.
Reply
lunatune 10-12-2009 @ 8:37PM
Look at the man!! Who, regardless of size, could care about anything he says?!
Reply
Lotte 10-12-2009 @ 10:37PM
THANK YOU! This is one extremely hideous looking man...wait, is he a man? Frankly, I would run screaming into the night if I saw this freak in a dark alley! Who CARES what these people think? Not the REAL women out here!
And REAL men are men like "b" and John! Thank you gentleman!
Hope 10-14-2009 @ 12:47PM
haha you're one of the few people actually talking sense on this thing! :)
thankyouuuuuu
punkycolour 10-12-2009 @ 8:48PM
Coco Chanel broke down barriers in order to liberate women in the fashion world. She must be rolling over in her grave...
Reply
Debi Drecksler 10-13-2009 @ 4:42PM
I just posted a column 10/12/09 at www.debidrecksler.com called Beautiful At Any Size.
I do not agree with Karl Lagerfeld!!
Reply
KadyL 10-13-2009 @ 7:22AM
I am most definitely in agreement that women are beautiful no matter what size they are, however, there comes a point when being too over weight is unhealthy. Having too much body fat can lead to many problems with your heart, joints and other vital parts as well.
Do I think that women should be required to look anorexic to model? No, absolutely not. I think that it gives bad images to "regular" women/girls. But, I also think that people need to stop bashing the women who model... maybe they really do have a problem with their bodies.
Growing up I was always very thin, and I had kids in school make fun of me all the time, asking if I was anorexic. Out of school, I had adults telling me to eat more, that I should fatten up. It has taken YEARS for me to gain a higher level of comfort with my own body.
It's just not fair to have a double standard like this. As a very skinny woman it is not socially acceptable for me to go up to a fat women and say "you're too fat", so why is it acceptable for someone to come up to me and say "you're too skinny"?
Pedro 10-13-2009 @ 4:23PM
I believe there is a deeper problem with many of today's fashion designers in general: They couldn't care less about women... They only care about their "art". The fact that women have to wear their creations is bothersome to them... They hate curves that tug and push their fabulous fabrics out of place. Their ideal woman is a stick figure: nothing that takes precedence over their creation. In earlier times, couture was about making women look beautiful... now, these stick women are there to let the dress look beautiful, like glorified hangers.
Having a woman's body carry their "art" is a nuisance for these people, so the more insignificant the woman, the better... Notice also the make-up models are wearing: usually they look like corpses... They are symbolically "killing" the woman, so only their creation remains.
I know this sounds somewhat academic, but to me it makes sense... Before, women were the stars; now the star is the design, and hence, the designer...
When Lagerfeld says "no one wants to see fat women," he actually means "none of us (designers) want to see their beautiful designs marred by women's bodies"
Nat 10-13-2009 @ 4:31PM
Thank you! Thank you! Thank you! for your comments Debi. I too am naturally very thin (5' 9" and 120 pounds) and was teased all through school and into my adult years for what was determined as being "too skinny". I had no control over my weight as I'm sure there are those overweight individuls that struggle with excess weight for different reasons. But to be so free to poke fun at someone for being underweight when god forbid anyone comment about the overweight folks is a ridiculous double standard. When someone calls me skinny I ask them if they would be offended if in turn commented that they were fat , there response is always "but being called skinny is a compliment". It's not to me!
Mariela 10-12-2009 @ 8:51PM
He's a total idiot and not too handsom himself, better eat more Karl, you just might look sexier!
Reply
"b" 10-12-2009 @ 8:48PM
I could care less about what this kraut idiot thinks
Reply
lucki 10-12-2009 @ 8:50PM
An ugly man, inside and out, who refuses to change with the times.
Reply