Blackface on 'America's Next Top Model'
Filed under: Beauty, News, Makeup
Nicole Fox strikes a pose on "America's Next Top Model." Photo courtesy of The CW
On the episode, which aired tonight (Oct. 28), host Tyra Banks said the goal was to create an editorial celebration of the "Hapa" (that's Hawaiian for mixed-race) children of immigrants who relocated to Hawaii to work as sugar cane farmers in the mid-19th century. Barack Obama is the most famous Hapa.
Banks tasked models with interpreting exotic racial combinations like "Russian-Moroccan," "Native American-East Indian," and "Botswanan-Polynesian," photographing them herself in the green reeds of a sugar plantation on the island of Maui.
Then, the models were sent to makeup, where each was painted with varying degrees of dark body makeup to match the perceived skin tone of the corresponding race they were conveying.
This is the second time models have been shown in dark makeup in recent weeks.
French Vogue photographed model Lara Stone in blackface for its October issue, which was particularly disturbing because the offending pictures were part of an issue celebrating models, but had nary a black model in the magazine.
Instead, they chose to paint a blonde model black in a botched attempt to squeeze out a drop of artistic diversity.
Currently, out of "America's Next Top Model's" six remaining contestants, one is black, one is Asian and four are Caucasian. The show started out with four black models in a group of 14.
We asked experts to weigh in on the issue. Here's what they had to say:
Susan Stiffelman, Marriage and Family therapist and author of Parenting Without Power Struggles: "While the images shown on 'America's Top Model' were interesting and compelling, our culture is still quite young in terms of its ethnic maturity. Promoting women of color in traditional -- stereotypical -- attire and settings may have been motivated by a desire to celebrate diversity, but the photo shoot runs the risk of perpetuating stereotypes that women have long been working to dismantle.
"It's especially important to consider the effect on young women (the show's primary viewers) of having Caucasian models made up to simulate women of color, rather than having -- well, women of color being celebrated for their beauty. It could be considered a rather significant throwback to a time when people of African descent were excluded from mainstream theater and the arts, with white actors and performers substituted, with blackface.
Jennifer An in a headdress on "America's Next Top Model." Photo: Courtesy of The CW
"I would hope that a program that showcases the extraordinary beauty of women from every background would emphasize the beauty of each individual with the unique features, coloring and characteristics they were born with. This helps young girls and women embrace their own look, rather than fueling their desire to look like someone other than themselves."
Deborah Padilla, New York City Makeup Artist: "I think Tyra was using it as a platform to bring awareness to the issue, and not be offensive. There was an obvious theme. I thought she came up with a concept and executed it. The pictures were beautiful! But it's so easily for these things to get lost in translation.
"But I find it weird and question the motive of the photographer who shot the issue of French Vogue. The aim was to celebrate black models. So, why not use models of color? They are tons that are readily available. It's like a slap in the face. To not use black models and use blackface puts a different spin that makes it weird."
What do you think? Did you find this episode offensive? Was it in poor taste to feature models in dark makeup or was it all in the name of celebrating diversity? Take the poll, and leave a comment!
Deborah Padilla, New York City Makeup Artist: "I think Tyra was using it as a platform to bring awareness to the issue, and not be offensive. There was an obvious theme. I thought she came up with a concept and executed it. The pictures were beautiful! But it's so easily for these things to get lost in translation.
"But I find it weird and question the motive of the photographer who shot the issue of French Vogue. The aim was to celebrate black models. So, why not use models of color? They are tons that are readily available. It's like a slap in the face. To not use black models and use blackface puts a different spin that makes it weird."
What do you think? Did you find this episode offensive? Was it in poor taste to feature models in dark makeup or was it all in the name of celebrating diversity? Take the poll, and leave a comment!












rashaundajones 10-29-2009 @ 4:59AM
I think they look great. I am a very proud Black woman and I do not take any offense to what they are doing. It's great to see the many different beautiful hues of black skin. I love it. Tyra is awesome. (They need to have more African American models to represent the complete beauty of the race.)
Reply
dawntel 10-29-2009 @ 3:28PM
I think that the photos are beautiful! Tyra did an excellent job! What is the big fuss about? Becuase they didn't use black people???? Um.... who cares? It's 2009 not 1936 grow up people. Is this going to be a conflict everytime a model of a different ethnic background portrays somthing she isn't? Excuse me if Im wrong, but isn't that what models do?
AmandaN8Vpride 10-29-2009 @ 3:30PM
They only had one model that was portraying a black-mixed girl. The rest were of other mixes which also includes beautiful hues of brown. You RARELY ever see a Native American model and I remember seeing what the mix Native American/Eastern Indian model looked like and I was not at all offended...however it would be nice to show the world what the beauty of a Native American woman really looks like, not a fake one. The photographs were wonderful though and very creative.
dejeve 10-29-2009 @ 3:57PM
and if the writer actually watched the episode they whitened down Sundai's face (a black girl) and put a lot of pink in her cheeks.... they were trying to make her look Russian, AKA white....
but i love the writer's ATTEMPT to try and make this about a black thing only....
Mrblue 10-29-2009 @ 6:38PM
Read Mrblue's post at 6:27 P/M its right on the point!
Mrblue 10-29-2009 @ 10:29PM
read Mrblue's thread at 10:27 P/M
Christina 10-29-2009 @ 3:20PM
I don't see what the big deal is. ANTM has done this type of shoot before, making the girls different races: African, Italian, Asian, and yes, Caucasian.
Reply
jason 10-29-2009 @ 3:20PM
If anyone's interested in working online, Here's my how to video on
youtube
www.youtube.com/watch?v=GtmJGx4Z8P0
Reply
megaplexxxman 10-29-2009 @ 3:24PM
geez, lighten up idiots!!! what's wrong with a "kizzy girl" action every once in a while?
Reply
misterrs58 10-29-2009 @ 3:27PM
I completely agree with rashoundajones, these's absolutely nothing wrong with such innocent personal expression of one's appreciation for other cultures and or races. And attacking someone without knowing their intentions is every bit as rude and offensive, as it gets. This is a free country for heaven's sake! To respect each others rights and liberties, we must all give people the benefit of the doubt, first, before assuming the worst!
Reply
radicaltomato 10-29-2009 @ 3:28PM
Hillarious!!!...White people have been going to the beaches and tanning salons for decades, A little make up, BIG DEAL!!
Reply
tonya 10-29-2009 @ 9:35PM
u said a mouth full. no one seems to that being a problem. so what is the big deal. and this is not the first time that antm has done this type of photos. so tell those with little minds to get on board or stay out of the tanning beds all year long
uncle tom 10-29-2009 @ 3:33PM
GREAT FREE PUBLICITY HEH?
Reply
neshA 10-29-2009 @ 3:59PM
its not really that big of a deal......
Reply
Allie 10-29-2009 @ 3:46PM
I think people take things too personally. Lighten up! Enjoy the show or don't watch. I wasn't offended at all...obviously :)
Reply
Superslizcer 10-29-2009 @ 3:44PM
if anything it should be a compliment that they want to look like a black person
Reply
somepeoplearesodumb 10-29-2009 @ 4:54PM
Superslizcer you are very ignorant!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!11
tallcoolbeauty 10-29-2009 @ 3:43PM
As a Black woman and fan of ANTM, I really don't see a problem with the makeup. I watched the episode last night and I thought the models looked beautiful. I think it is time to stop looking for racism in every innocent action.
Reply
sickofhearingit 10-29-2009 @ 8:22PM
i completely agree with you, but these days,you cant have a decent conversation without someone going oooh thats racist or oooh thats sexist, and when i was on the school bus today, one of the girls said that shes gonna be a cowgirl for halloween. one of the guys on the bus was like ooooooh thats so sexist. its impossible not to offend anyone.
mrblue 10-29-2009 @ 3:46PM
I think its tacky its would be even tackier to paint a black women's face with white paint....Just use a woman of color to do the modeling, Are they trying to find away to not use black models? looks like wig head Karen Brown of Yeadon the stripper. VERY TACKY !!!
Reply