Waif Jacquelyn Jablonski in a fashion face-off with womanly Crystal Renn. Photo courtesy of V Magazine
As we reported last week, the next issue of
V magazine will celebrate
women of all shapes and all sizes -- including
plus-size.
And although the sure-to-be-controversial issue (#63) doesn't hit newsstands until Jan. 14, we got a sneak peek at one of the fashion stories.
Photographer
Terry Richardson's story, dubbed 'One Size Fits All,' features plus-size model/author
Crystal Renn -- a 5 ft, 9 in. beauty with 36-31-41 measurements -- opposite model-on-the-rise
Jacquelyn Jablonski who stands at the same height as
Renn, but with more
waifish stats: 32-24-34.
Both women, shown in side-by-side images, strike similar poses and don identical and often vibrantly patterned ensembles by the likes of
Ralph Lauren,
Proenza Schouler and
Dolce & Gabbana with bold accessories by
Versace,
Burberry and
Alexis Bittar.
One spread (shown above) features both models wearing the ubiquitous
bodysuit and
innerwear as outerwear trend, here, in the form of a fully visible bra, both by
Dolce & Gabbana.
The point of the spread is apparent -- to show that size doesn't matter and fashion can flatter a multitude of figures. Now, if only all the fashion designers would include plus-sizes in their collections, we'd be getting somewhere.
http://xml.channel.aol.com/xmlpublisher/fetch.v2.xml?option=expand_relative_urls&dataUrlNodes=uiConfig,feedConfig,localizationConfig,entry&id=804301&pid=804300&uts=1264007777
http://www.aolcdn.com/ke/media_gallery/v1/ke_media_gallery_wrapper.swf
V Magazine - One Size Fits All
V Magazine tackles the size issue by showing two models with two very different body types wearing the exact same thing.
Terry Richardson
V Magazine - One Size Fits All
Jacquelyn Jablonski (left) and Crystal Renn (right) wear Ralph Lauren tops, Proenza Schouler skirts, Viktor & Rolf belts, shoes by Versace, clutches by Giorgio Armani, socks by We Love Colors, scrunchies by Marc Jacobs, earrings, purple necklace and gold bangle by Patricia von Musulin, yellow cuff with spikes by M.C.L. by Matthew Campbell Laurence and rod necklaces, rings and the rest of the bangles by Alexis Bittar.
V Magazine - One Size Fits All
All the single ladies... Jablonski and Renn rock Beyonce-like bodysuits and bras by Dolce & Gabbana, leather belts by Burberry Prorsum, bangles worn in hair by Patricia Field, gold necklaces, blue-and-yellow jeweled and leopard bangles by Alexis Bittar, Lucite bangles with ivory inset by Patricia von Musulin and red-and-gray necklaces and the remaining bangles by Cara Croninger.
V Magazine - One Size Fits All
Whip it good. Jablonski and Renn wear Versace tops, skirt and shoes by Proenza Schouler, belt by Kokin, socks by We Love Colors, bangles (worn in hair), silver, blue-and-yellow jeweled and Lucite bangles by Alexis Bittar, Lucite necklace by Alexis Bittar for Michael Kors, gold bangles by Patricia von Musulin, black-and-white striped cuffs by Giorgio Armani and black-and-gray necklaces, red bangles and blue marbled cuffs by Cara Croninger.
V Magazine - One Size Fits All
Jablonski and Renn wear illustrated dresses by Danielle Scutt, belts by Giorgio Armani, shoes by Pierre Hardy, socks by We Love Colors, yellow and heart necklaces, blue marbled cuffs and Lucite rings by Cara Croninger, green necklaces and gold bangles by Patricia von Musulin, purple Lucite bangles by Burberry Prorsum, clear Lucite and blue jeweled bangles by Alexis Bittar and blue cuffs with spikes by M.C.L by Matthew Campbell Laurence.
V Magazine - One Size Fits All
But we want to know who
you think best worked the looks. Leave a
comment.
To see Crystal Renn in a more natural state (read: naked), check out
this Glamour magazine photo shoot.
my2cents 12-22-2009 @ 12:09PM
It's sad that she's considered "plus-sized". To me, she should be considered average, healthy sized as opposed to the skinny, emaciated look so many strive to be. Just shows how distorted our perceptions have become at what "ideal" (beautiful) is.
Reply
susf 12-24-2009 @ 3:01PM
AMEN!! The "plus size" (translation: NORMAL size!) model looks SO, SO much better! Let's lose the waif-look!
nycschoolgirl 1-03-2010 @ 9:06PM
The "real" model looks much much better. But its still important to note that she is thin. She is not stick like sickening like the other "high fashion" model--but she still doesn't adequately represent American women's bodies. Its a start...............
maddiej624 1-02-2010 @ 8:48PM
i totally agree. its ridiculous. She looks healthy, and most models are small. i understand the fashion world is difficult and harsh, but i know i would rather look at a "plus sized" model modeling my clothes than her. Its sick. The skinny model looks like shes sick. i feel i can relate more to the "plus size" because its more of a regular body, and thats how it would really look on an average american woman. ridiculous
Rachel 1-02-2010 @ 11:04PM
True dat! the so called plus size model actually has muscles! the other one is a little stick. the left model stops eating to loose weight, the one on the right works her butt off until all she has left is muscles
sunrise 1-03-2010 @ 12:33AM
I agree 100%. At 5'9" with the measurements what size would that make the "plus-sized" model? The smaller model looks sick especially her legs in the second picture. How many times have we read about the drugs and eating disorders the waif models have. Stop sending the wrong message to women. Adolesent and teen girls are very suseptable to this type of advertising.
Fran 1-03-2010 @ 1:00AM
I agree with you completely! She is normal size. There is no "plus-size" woman with a waist of 31 inches. That is a size 12 in pants. They need to revamp their thinking. And here people wonder why our teenage girls don't want to eat anything and are always worried about how they look. It is the society that are growing up in.
silvermoon 1-03-2010 @ 1:27AM
I agree. She is not plus sized in the least. If we live in a society where that first girl is worshipped for being a twig and that second girl is considered plus-sized, the future looks bleak indeed. I think that the women in ancient art, where a voluptuous woman was considered beautiful, were lucky women indeed, because they were not pressured by society to be unhealthily thin like this, nor were they ridiculed if they were not. Being a woman in today's society is hard enough without having to look like this to be considered beautiful.
cat 1-03-2010 @ 4:39AM
i agree with you, she is definitely average...and i hate how she's considered plus size, thanks for posting that
catlin 1-03-2010 @ 6:40AM
jeeze! she is not plus sized. that is just stupid to say. skinny girl makes me feel like i can never look good in those clothes and the "plus sized" girl makes me feel like i could actually wear that outfit.
the only girls i ever see that skinny are the ones that dont eat.
showing girls that all sizes can look good in clothes is a great message, but actually show a plus sized girl in them, not a normal sized girl. saying that the girl on the right is plus sized is telling girls that normal is fat.
and showing their sizes is so wrong. girls are going to get out their measuring tapes to see if they are considered plus size also.
we have enough to worry about.
Savona 1-03-2010 @ 8:03AM
I really agree with your comment. We need to all speak up more.
Joseph Burgess 1-03-2010 @ 1:46PM
The so called "plus" model looks much better, the other is way to small.
Deborah (registered dietitian) 1-03-2010 @ 3:10PM
I completely agree with you my2cents. It would be wonderful if actual plus-sized models could be included, truly celebrating how beauty and health come in all shapes and sizes!
Hi There Baby 12-22-2009 @ 1:53PM
Why isn't there a poll to vote on? Lets see what most "regular" people think is sexier ?
Reply
ASummersFae 12-24-2009 @ 7:08AM
I wouldn't consider their "plus size model" actually plus size, but she looks better in both outfits. The other one looks sickly
Reply
Jsquare 12-24-2009 @ 7:33AM
I think who they are calling the plus size model wears it better. She actually represents most of the women in this country. Which by the way is not really what you would call plus.
Reply
meme 1-02-2010 @ 9:28PM
What the hell is Plus Size?Do they mean fat?It is pretty sad when normal size in america is fat,no wonder there is so many fat people in america.And if Plus Size means fat why dont they say Minus Size for those not fat?Its also sad people cant think for themselfs,the meida and washingtion tells you what to say and you do so without question.Thanks P.C.
jan 12-24-2009 @ 8:19AM
The "plus" size model looks like a woman. The other model looks loke a little girl. Honestly, if I saw the plus size by itself, I wouldn't even question if she was plus size.
Reply
shadow 1-02-2010 @ 9:34PM
Thank you for saying that!! The "plus size model" isn't even plus size. The stick thin model is undernourished. That's how everyone has been brainwashed. The real plus size models are in the hanes underwear commercial. Size 14 - 16 and up.
Mary 1-02-2010 @ 11:59PM
Actually, plus-sizes start beyond 14. My mom is a 14 and plus-sized clothing doesn't fit her at all. This model is SO not even nearing a plus-size. The clothes must be sewn/made to fit her because actual plus-sized clothes would not fit her at all. I'm guessing she's a size six. There are no words to describe how messed up it is to call THIS plus-sized.