Thrift Store Shopping: 14 Reader Tips For Buying Secondhand At Goodwill, Salvation Army Stores

HuffPost Social Reading

When we mention thrift stores, people tend to have strong reactions (positive or negative). So, when we posted our thrift shopping secrets, we weren't sure what the response would be. Luckily, our readers didn't let us down -- you love thrift stores, too! So much in fact, that we decided to revisit the topic.

Click through the slideshow below for 14 more awesome thrift tips straight from you, our readers. From going with grandma to visiting Goodwill online, there's more than enough to make your next visit to the thrift store even more of a success.

Front Page Flickr Photo by pixeljones

Thrift Tip: Original Packaging
1  of  15
PLAY
FULLSCREEN
ZOOM
SHARE THIS SLIDE 
"I am especially drawn to items that are still in the original boxes. BUT, take the item out and make sure it is in tact. I bought a beautiful jewelry box for my granddaughter's bedroom here to put a small amount of jewelry in when she visits. It was brand new and I paid less than $3 for it. She will love it." -Virginia Dewire

Flickr Photo by nezumichuu
RATE IT!   |  
VOTE
CURRENT TOP 5 PICK YOUR OWN TOP 5
USERS WHO VOTED
NEW! CREATE YOUR OWN SLIDESHOW

 
  • Comments
  • 32
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Comments are closed for this entry
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
07:10 PM on 01/30/2012
It seems like I read a comment here (but can't find it) where they said to go on Sunday morning from 10 to 12 because if you live in an area like mine where the color for 1/2 off changes on Sundays, they remove a lot of the things with that color on them for the week. I think they are correct. I went to one today and the color of the week is blue. I swear there were a ton of books with a blue label on them on Saturday. I only saw a couple today and it looks like half the books are gone. Kind of sneaky, if you ask me.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
01:43 PM on 01/30/2012
My most UNUSUAL & useful find at an independen­­t thrift store was boxes & boxes of used parquet square wood tiles that fit into each other.They had some type of black residue on the bottom.I bought all they had which was at least 10 boxes at $8.00 a box.Not typical size boxes they come in but larger.I took them home, rough sanded them a little on bottom & top.I installed them myself (they interlocke­­d together) had EXACTLY enough to cover my entire living room,hall,­& adjoining dining room.I put the floor glue on thick!After it dried I damp mopped them,let dry again & polyurenth­­aned them all.It was GORGEOUS & I liked the vintage marks etc.left on them wherever they'd been.(I heard rumor an old store)They SHINED like new "distre­sse­d" wood floor.So I covered 2 rooms+hall with a real wood floor over old linoleum for a little over $100.00! Pe­ople still are amazed when I tell them I bought 2+rooms flooring from a "thrift" store! My old house is in is now a rental,onc­e there was a leak from a nearby pipe that didn't leak too long thank goodness.N­OT ONE piece of wood tile came up! My husband thought I was nuts for putting so much"goo"under each piece.Glad I did now.Probab­­ly a once in a lifetime find!
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
07:02 AM on 01/30/2012
When I weed through my closets for clothes I don't need or want anymore, the department store stuff goes out the door before the thrift store stuff. That's because my thrift store finds are mostly designer items that look and fit better than anything I can afford to buy new, even on sale. Resale rules!
04:19 AM on 01/30/2012
Be aware that behind Goodwill's closed doors the employees are treated like they are in the Third World. If ever an organization desperately needed a union, this one is it. Distrust and disrespect are routine. The waste is astronomical...serviceable clothing, housewares, and toys are thrown away by the melon full. Donated to homeless shelters, clothing banks, distribution outlets for the destitute, children's hospitals, teddy bears to local police departments, Marine Corps Toys for Tots? Not on your life. Some of it goes to a few big-city outlets but much of it, especially at stores far from the outlets, is either resold to wholesalers or tossed. Check out websites where employees can review their employers and read for yourself. How do I know all of this? I work there... and along with most of the hourly staff I am trying to find another job.
04:15 AM on 01/30/2012
I have found great things at thrift shops, like a Marilyn jewelry box and 3 photo of her in black and white in a curved frame. for $25,00. Flea markets are great too. I got an art deco jewelry box for $20,00, Let's not forget Amazon and EBay.
01:52 AM on 01/30/2012
When you buy an article of clothing new at a regular retail store you always have to buy a little larger to allow for shrinkage when first laundered. This is always something of a crap shoot since it may shrink more or less depending on how it was manufactured. When you buy a shirt second hand you know you are getting exactly the right fit because you've tried it on at the store and it's already been through the wash.
10:52 PM on 01/29/2012
That one tip was. "don't discourge people from buying upholstered furniture, by state law they have to sprayed and treated and tagged

Yeah sure.

We bought an upholstered rocker that was tagged in this manner. Asked the Goodwill employee what the tag meant. She said they have been sprayed for bedbugs. Our boys bought it home Sunday night, we were sitting in the LR Monday night, watching the bedbugs crawling out. It has been about 3 mos. , we spray and spray, still have the pests. They reproduce every 3 weeks. and every 3 weeks we get another outbreak.

Contrary to what the article says. DON'T BUY UPHOLSTERED FURNITURE AT GOODWILL. You have heard the truth, for you own good, please heed it.

Otherwise, you can get good deals on clothing, if you shop carefully.
10:34 PM on 01/29/2012
When I had my house (before it was foreclosed on), I went to Goodwill to buy decorator items like candlesticks and vases and such. Now I go to buy things to resell. I've found two Limoges trinket boxes that I paid less than $1 for each one. One I sold for $44 and the other one just sold for $40. ebay used to be my "2nd" job. Now it's my "1st".
isisreptiles
I make no apologies for being who I am.
08:43 PM on 01/29/2012
There are lots of thrift stores where I live, both the national ones like Goodwill and Salvation Army, and those run by local charities. I've noticed that the ones run by the local charities tend to have better prices than the national ones.
08:41 PM on 01/29/2012
I work at a thrift store in MN. that is a non-profit & volunteers only work there, it donates it's income back to the community, based on food, clothing and shelter needs in our county. Since 1981 we have donated $1,423,000.00 back to the community to churches, food shelves etc. Thanks to all the wonderful donations.
07:19 PM on 01/29/2012
T. Ronald Dixon, you offered them $1.50 for the pair because the $1 a piece was too expensive for a pair of Goebel candle holders? I really can't stand cheap people like you!!
02:16 AM on 01/30/2012
I agree. I quit having garage sales because no matter how low I priced something some cheapskate wanted it for less. Now I just give it away to charity thrift shops.
04:51 PM on 01/29/2012
The best buy was my kitchen knotty pine tounge and groove wood floor (formerly panelling ) with many cabinet doors for $50.00. My husband flipped the bosrds and finished the back side. I also got a 1930 gas range on legs for $50.00. Just made my country kitchen.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
03:36 PM on 01/29/2012
Big Name thifts stores are really pricey in my areal!BUT there's more stores w/physically-mentally challenged people working for them also.One's for housing/help for abused women&their children.They give women/children vouchers 4 essentials to hopefully start new life because they've left in hurry-had NOTHING.Vouchers were 4 clothes 4 each family member,utensils,pans,cooking,bedding,baby items,all things WE take 4 granted.They seem so grateful for start to hopefully a new life.If they move into apt/house later given vouchers 4furniture.Store never gives location of shelter.They give vouchers to Men starting over 4many reasons,have separate location for them.So I'm getting bargains+helping people.PricesRGREAT all clothing $1.00.Jackets,linens marked 1 Price! 1shop I go to ALL clothing 50 cents!These stores have bag days anything clothes fits in a bag is $3.00-$5.00. Sometimes other items.Also check stores supporting Humane societies,animal rescues.They usually have shop cats that give love 4 free! I see pics cats/dogs rescued,needing new home always end up donating extra in the "kitty".We've many dogs/cats that were dumped at our home&we're at our limit+Seniors.But found these shelters accepted them,tried to find homes/NO KILL-my heart goes out to them&their work.So PLEASE look up humane societies,help for battered women etc,ASK if they have thrift stores-prices MUCH lower,they're always individual/unique stores.Stores I share w/others-they don't have budget to advertise!
photo
MISTERUNCONVENTIONAL
The only attitude I've ever had is a bad one.
08:45 PM on 01/26/2012
When you're in the thrift store, check the pockets of every clothing item you are considering buying. I've had men's suits pay for themselves more than once.
10:28 PM on 01/29/2012
And handbags. I found a $100 bill folded under the piece of cardboard they put in the bottom of the purse to keep it's structure. I took it back to Goodwill, but they said it was mine since I bought the purse and they didn't find it.
photo
MISTERUNCONVENTIONAL
The only attitude I've ever had is a bad one.
10:35 AM on 01/30/2012
Next time I find $ I'll make it a donation. Last time my greed and excitement got the better of me. I'm proud of you for trying.
photo
MISTERUNCONVENTIONAL
The only attitude I've ever had is a bad one.
08:42 PM on 01/26/2012
The trick to thrift shopping is to go almost EVERY DAY.

And if you can't do that, give someone who DOES a $100 budget to buy ANYTHING they think you might like or want. The winners will so outpace the losers you won't mind when they bring home a groaner. And never whine when they do or you may miss out on a REAL winner.

Over the course of a year, I saw virtually every item I had ever owned or paid full price for at a thrift store for 10% or so, including a pair of correct-size Sidi bicycling shoes in mint condition. Retail: $299. Thrift: $7.

Bloggers

 
 
Kirsten Dirksen , Co-founder, faircompanies.com

Discuss "craft" with Scott Constable, whose training includes apprenticeships under master woodworkers and who specialization in traditional joinery, and you're...

Read Post | Comments
Lisa Holt , In-house Interior Designer, NapaStyle; Creative Director, DLS Hotels & Spas

It isn't always easy to please everyone's palate (and possible dietary requirements) when creating a menu for a party, but...

Read Post | Comments
Rana Florida , CEO, The Creative Class Group

Target's innovations in design have dramatically raised its profile, setting it above its rivals. It just announced "The Shops at...

Read Post | Comments
Marcia Prentice , Interior Designer and blogger, Style Illuminated by LAMPS PLUS

Summer is almost here! Now that the days and nights are much warmer, having an outdoor ceiling fan can help...

Read Post | Comments
Bonnie McCarthy , Design expert, writer, photographer

Globe trekkers Heather Morrison and Neil Navin brought back more than trinkets and souvenirs from time spent living in the...

Read Post | Comments
Mary Hall , The Recessionista

Both Philip Treacy and Christopher Guy Harrison must have spent time reading the original Alice in Wonderland with illustrations by...

Read Post | Comments
Condiment , Condiment is a digital lifestyle magazine about tasting the good life through unique and upstart products

The minute you meet Apt2b.com's founder, Mat Herman, you instantly get why the upstart retail site is getting the buzz...

Read Post | Comments
Oyster , Oyster.com visits, photographs, reviews and rates each hotel. We uncover the truth, before it's "uh-oh" time.

These fantasies can very easily become a reality, with an outdoor space and a little elbow grease. We've seen a...

Read Post | Comments
Kelly Cogswell , Lesbian activist, independent journalist and award-winning columnist, Gay City News

I was mortified to learn that in the 1970s and '80s IKEA used slave labor. That's what it's called when...

Read Post | Comments
Courtney Cachet , Designer, TV Personality, Style Expert, Writer, Ninja

I have a lot of friends who could be called crafty. You know the type: They try new recipes, make...

Read Post | Comments
Robin Wilson , Wellness expert, leading eco-friendly interior designer

As you return to your summer home, there are many things on the maintenance list and given the damp weather...

Read Post | Comments
George Hobica , Syndicated travel journalist and founder of Airfarewatchdog.com

During the 20th century, a group of architects staged a controversial revolt. Why, they asked, couldn't less be as impressive...

Read Post | Comments
Fawn Galli , Founder, Fawn Galli Interior Design

The manipulation of light, through the use of paints, fabrics, and lighting, should always be one of the first considerations...

Read Post | Comments
Susan Cahill , Author

Paris is more and more a green city. The current mayor, Bernard Delanoe, has added more than 100 new acres...

Read Post | Comments

Stylelist Home TV