Buying Guide: Mattress Reviews (PHOTOS)

HuffPost Social Reading

The mattress is probably among the most important and personal home items you own. We all know we're supposed to get seven hours of sleep (at least) each day--and a bad mattress will definitely prevent that from happening.

What it comes down to with a mattress is your own personal comfort and how it can support your body specifically. While the comfort level of a mattress varies from person to person and the construction of mattresses can be broken down to a science, one thing is certain when you're looking to purchase one: It's a big investment and you better make sure it works for you.

Thus, we took note of some of the general things to keep in mind if you're in the market for a mattress, whether it's a memory foam or a regular spring mattress.

Know the types. For the most part there are three main mattress types: inner spring, latex and memory foam. There are, of course, also air mattresses and ones made up of latex foam, but mattresses at most stores generally stick to the above three. Our pick: Latex (Find out why below)

Ask about inner springs. Without going too much into the intricacies of construction, inner spring coil mattresses are the most common and cost-effective, and they tend to be firm. Ask about the type of support wire coils in a spring mattress. There are four types: open (hourglass shape), offset (square top), pocket (individually fabric wrapped cylinders) or continuous (S-shaped). Out of the the four, open coil support wears out most easily and continuous coils provide the best evenly distributed support. Our Pick: Continuous coils

Going latex. Made from all-natural latex rubber, this mattress option is hypoallergenic and dust-mite resistant. Not too firm and not too plush, latex is a good choice for people who might be suffering from back pains, and it also retains heat well. Many go for 9"-12" thick latex mattresses, which has more layers of latex rubber inside, and don't go below 6", but this is highly dependent on your specific comfort level. We've found the 7"-10" range to be a good fit for us.

The memory-foam. The most well known body-molding, memory-foam mattress is by Tempurpedic. What's important to know about memory-foam is that it heats up much more than other mattresses as it isn't as breathable as latex or spring mattresses. However, its firmness has been said to provide much better cushioning than innerspring mattresses, but memory-foam usually comes with a much high price tag.

Be firm with firmness. Contrary to popular opinion, a firm mattress is not always best. An extremely firm mattress can actually provide uneven support and end up putting stress on body parts like the hips and shoulders. Likewise for a mattress that is too soft, making you sink and thus causing body aches. However, one tried and true tip is to go with a medium-firm (or cushion-firm) mattress, like a latex foam one, if you suffer from lower back pains -- it gives better support to the spine's curve. Our pick: Medium-firmness

Don't buy online. This goes without saying, but you'd be surprised at how many people succumb to the convenience of purchasing a mattress over the internet these days. You should check out mattresses in person and definitely lie down on one to test it out in the store to make sure it's comfortable for you. Not to mention, shipping costs can be high, which would make an already expensive purchase even more costly.

Price points. There are mattresses that go for under $1,000 but most people tend to invest that amount into one. Some mattresses can cost thousands of dollars (even tens of thousands of dollars), but in general, we find that one that costs anywhere from $500-$1200 with the right support is satisfactory and easy to find at chains like Sleepy's and department stores such as Macy's.

If you're shopping around for a mattress now or thinking about getting one in the near future, here are a few options to get you started, and don't forget to check out the shopping video also. And let us know in comments below what other factors are important to you in a mattress.

Front page Flickr photo by Flashy Soup Can


RATE IT!   |  
VOTE
CURRENT TOP 5 PICK YOUR OWN TOP 5
USERS WHO VOTED
NEW! CREATE YOUR OWN SLIDESHOW

 
  • Comments
  • 63
  • Pending Comments
  • 0
  • View FAQ
Post Comment Preview Comment
To reply to a Comment: Click "Reply" at the bottom of the comment; after being approved your comment will appear directly underneath the comment you replied to.
View All
Favorites
Recency  | 
Popularity
Page: 1 2  Next ›  Last »  (2 total)
01:29 PM on 02/03/2012
Sleep number for me...it was a little expensive, but so worth it! Sleep like a baby...and if you want, you can change the settings. My wife likes her side more firm while I like mine soft and cozy. :-)
11:52 AM on 02/03/2012
We've ussed a sleep number bed for over 20 years. We wouldn't have any other kind. His side is at 90, and mine is at 50. We love it.
09:55 AM on 02/03/2012
I thought a firm mistress would give me a better nights sleep than the lumpy one I have now.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
01:32 AM on 01/31/2012
part 2
Never ever buy online even if you think it's the same mattress you saw in the store. Stores generally carry SIMILAR models but each retailer asks for different things in their mattresses to make them stand apart from each other. Just because it's called a sealy regal in one store doesn't make it the same sealy regal in a different store. Everything from the fabrics to the thickness of the foams can be totally different. Consider the price too. You DO get what you pay for! And guess what..there is no such thing as an "overstock". Most manufactures don't stockpile their mattresses. Even small private label manufacturers generally make only what they will sell within a few days what with the costs of materials and storage. Better yet support a local manufacturer over the big boys as they offer better pricing because they aren't spending millions to advertise (and you are probably helping your local economy by keeping jobs in the area).
01:26 AM on 01/31/2012
Back pain is different for every one. Sciatica people like firm but the other half need soft. There is no mattress that is specifically good for a blanket term like "back pain".
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Sachem515
Facts aren't negotiable
01:18 AM on 01/31/2012
Sleep Number

Cool and adjustable. Bye Bye Chiropractor.
12:31 AM on 01/31/2012
If you're a mattress salesperson, go to YouTube and search for "mattress salesman" you will die laughing because all mattress sales people can relate.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
BlueOnBlue
275 Republicans Voted to Kill Medicare
12:28 AM on 01/31/2012
We went with Tempupedic last year and we like the mattress a lot, but we really love the pillows which came with it. For me, a good pillow is much more important to a good night's sleep than the mattress. In fact, when we travel by car, we bring the pillows with us.
01:34 AM on 01/31/2012
Hello! The pillow is the mattress for your head and it must work in conjunction with your mattress for correct spinal alignment.
photo
Hoonieman
Enjoy yourself; it's later than you think ..
11:28 PM on 01/30/2012
No matter what mattress one choses, alway make sure it doesn't contain PBDE's ..
06:57 PM on 01/31/2012
Wool is naturally resistent to flame, and is an excellent bedding material (cool in the summer, and warm in the winter). It also breaths better than synthetic materials, is naturally antibacterial, and wicks away moisture to keep you comfortable throughout the night. Why US bed makers don't use it in their bedding upholstery layers, overlain with a comfortable cotton or silk damask ticking, is a mystery to me. It is used very widely elsewhere. Perhaps not enough journalists know anything about a well-made bed. I guess they'd rather buy something cheaper, and spray it with PBDEs, and hope the consumer doesn't notice or ask any difficult questions. And really, does anybody smoke in bed anymore? Why must every bed made or imported into the US pass a very old and restrictive fire protection standard. Even places like Chicago did away with the restriction on building wood framed homes some decades or more after the Great Chicago Fire of 1871. Are US consumer regulators still having nightmares of Mrs. O'Leary's cow?
photo
Hoonieman
Enjoy yourself; it's later than you think ..
07:10 PM on 01/31/2012
Spot on .. thanks for this good advice ..
garystartswithg
el sueno de la razon produce republicans
11:07 PM on 01/30/2012
You can get an inexpensive qulited cover or pillowtop for the latex, problem solved, not my first choice for a foam matress but better than coils at the same price. I tend to run hot and memory foam is a really bad idea if you do -- you will wake up in a hole, they are heat sensitive, so if you overheat the matress will overcompensate.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
11:05 PM on 01/30/2012
The article ignores whether someone sleeps on their back, stomach or side. Usually (my opinion only) someone sleeping on their back prefers a firmer mattress while those on their stomach, prefer a softer one.
photo
HUFFPOST BLOGGER
Brie Dyas
12:50 PM on 01/31/2012
This is another good topic to raise--we polled the staff and most of us sleep in different positions. Do you think it would be helpful to have a buying guide for specific sleeping positions?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
05:07 PM on 01/31/2012
I do, thanks for asking. It's easy to make a mistake in buying a mattress and since people sleep in different positions, there doesn't seem to be hard and fast rules that apply to everyone.
10:09 PM on 01/30/2012
This article should have also alerted consumers to the toxicity of the majority of mattresses on the market. Mattresses are sprayed down with flame retardants that bio-accumulate and pose a serious health threats. Mattresses also off-gas volatile organic compounds from cheap glues other synthetic materials (polyurethane foam . . . derived from petroleum), which can seriously impair indoor air quality. Seriously, you spend about 1/3 of your life sleeping, so why would you want to subject your body to this kind of abuse? Soy "based" memory foam isn't green at all . . . it is usually 10-15% soybean oil based and 85% petro-chemicals.

Anyway, I had an organic bed custom built, and I couldn't be happier. I'd consider it a fairly wise investment . . .
photo
HTooley
keeper of the tower
10:00 PM on 01/30/2012
Been sleeping on a waterbed for years. Never woke up with a backache! No worry about beds. Fully supported and not so expensive. Of course it is harder to move around but not really a problem for me. My latest bed does not move once I'm on it. No 'sea sickness' effect at all. Land and Sky makes a good product. Something to think about...
photo
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
headly67
Well raise my rent
09:49 PM on 01/30/2012
I manage a retailer of mattresses and furniture for a living so if anyone has a question you can ask.

Bottom line, the more you spend the more support you will get.
Don't skimp on a mattress, spend 2-3 grand and it will last you for 15-20 years.

My store offers 4 years no interest so there is no excuse to go cheap.

My picks - TEMPURPEDIC -Contour Signature or Cloud Supreme - both $3000
HUFFPOST SUPER USER
Norm K
12:41 AM on 01/31/2012
okay, headly, here's a question: I HATE it when my bed warms up too much from my body heat. I would rather sleep atop a "too soft" or "too firm" mattress than a HOT one. I've been to mattress stores on roughly a dozen occasions as an adult, and told them SPECIFICALLY that I want a bed that doesn't absorb or reflect heat. Without fail, I have been upsold towards memory foam, despite the fact that this article, and many others I've seen, say "What's important to know about memory-foam is that it heats up much more than other mattresses as it isn't as breathable as latex or spring mattresses."

What sort of mattress would YOU recommend? do waterbeds stay cooler?
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
photo
09:08 AM on 02/03/2012
We have been using Coleman air mattresses from Target for about 15 years. They're great. I made toppers out of kapok............so, with the air mattress and the kapok topper.......they're soft and comfy and no bugs of any sort. You can either take the air mattress outside and hose it off after a while or just buy a new one. A simple (inexpensive) foam topper can also be used.

Our granddaughter wanted a futon so I made her one out of kapok.

I've made pillows out of kapok too.....no down feather disintegration or bugs. Hypo-allergenic too.

Kapok is grown in South America and is pesticide free. I buy mine online from a company down south. You can buy it bulk or in ready-made products. Yes, of course it is washable...needs to be 'fluffed' afterward.

What's that old ad? No bugs m'lady. :-)
12:52 AM on 01/31/2012
I'd like to take you up on your offer of answers.

I have an adjustable extra long full sized bed. Is there a bariatric mattress I could get for this size bed?

Thanks.
This user has chosen to opt out of the Badges program
09:09 PM on 01/30/2012
I have been sleeping on a Sleepmatters mattress fro about 6 years now and have never looked back.

Amazing comfort and support.

Made from a design used for burn victims' mattresses in hospitals who require less pressure for obvious reasons.

Had a temperpedic, gave it away, didn't like at all, too hot, felt cheap.

Bloggers

 
 
Kirsten Dirksen , Co-founder, faircompanies.com

Discuss "craft" with Scott Constable, whose training includes apprenticeships under master woodworkers and who specialization in traditional joinery, and you're...

Read Post | Comments
Lisa Holt , In-house Interior Designer, NapaStyle; Creative Director, DLS Hotels & Spas

It isn't always easy to please everyone's palate (and possible dietary requirements) when creating a menu for a party, but...

Read Post | Comments
Rana Florida , CEO, The Creative Class Group

Target's innovations in design have dramatically raised its profile, setting it above its rivals. It just announced "The Shops at...

Read Post | Comments
Marcia Prentice , Interior Designer and blogger, Style Illuminated by LAMPS PLUS

Summer is almost here! Now that the days and nights are much warmer, having an outdoor ceiling fan can help...

Read Post | Comments
Bonnie McCarthy , Design expert, writer, photographer

Globe trekkers Heather Morrison and Neil Navin brought back more than trinkets and souvenirs from time spent living in the...

Read Post | Comments
Mary Hall , The Recessionista

Both Philip Treacy and Christopher Guy Harrison must have spent time reading the original Alice in Wonderland with illustrations by...

Read Post | Comments
Condiment , Condiment is a digital lifestyle magazine about tasting the good life through unique and upstart products

The minute you meet Apt2b.com's founder, Mat Herman, you instantly get why the upstart retail site is getting the buzz...

Read Post | Comments
Oyster , Oyster.com visits, photographs, reviews and rates each hotel. We uncover the truth, before it's "uh-oh" time.

These fantasies can very easily become a reality, with an outdoor space and a little elbow grease. We've seen a...

Read Post | Comments
Kelly Cogswell , Lesbian activist, independent journalist and award-winning columnist, Gay City News

I was mortified to learn that in the 1970s and '80s IKEA used slave labor. That's what it's called when...

Read Post | Comments
Courtney Cachet , Designer, TV Personality, Style Expert, Writer, Ninja

I have a lot of friends who could be called crafty. You know the type: They try new recipes, make...

Read Post | Comments
Robin Wilson , Wellness expert, leading eco-friendly interior designer

As you return to your summer home, there are many things on the maintenance list and given the damp weather...

Read Post | Comments
George Hobica , Syndicated travel journalist and founder of Airfarewatchdog.com

During the 20th century, a group of architects staged a controversial revolt. Why, they asked, couldn't less be as impressive...

Read Post | Comments
Fawn Galli , Founder, Fawn Galli Interior Design

The manipulation of light, through the use of paints, fabrics, and lighting, should always be one of the first considerations...

Read Post | Comments
Susan Cahill , Author

Paris is more and more a green city. The current mayor, Bernard Delanoe, has added more than 100 new acres...

Read Post | Comments

Stylelist Home TV