Skip to Content

Passion for fashion? Visit the new StyleList!

The weight debate gets heavy

Filed under: Runway Trends, Style in the News

There was an uproar in the fashion world in fall 2006 when Madrid and Milan fashion weeks turned away models without a healthy BMI. Since then, a debate has erupted over why America hasn't taken a cue from its European counterparts and imposed a minimum weight restriction on models appearing in fashion shows. Recently, a new voice has joined the party and he has some personal insight into the problem.

Former Halston designer Bradley Bayou had witnessed the industry's sample sizes shrinking, and he went along with it. His oldest daughter constantly tried to lose enough weight so that she could fit into his designs and look as pretty as the models he dressed.

Bayou was unaware that his daughter suffered from an eating disorder (and that he'd been contributing to it) until she entered therapy after a breakdown that had landed her in the emergency room. It was then that he realized the impact that the skeletal fashion models have on women across the world. This was three years ago, and Bayou isn't about to stop spreading his message: Fashion Can Kill.

Are these designers using too-thin models?

(click thumbnails to view gallery)

  • Prada
  • Marc Jacobs
  • Heatherette
  • Diane von Furstenberg
  • Fendi
In addition to this account, a top Uruguayan fashion model dropped dead minutes after walking the catwalk from heart failure caused by her attempts to become a size zero (as encouraged by her agency). The question that reports like this bring into play is whether imposing a minimum weight regulation for models would fix the problem, and while Bayou is all for the regulation, some surprising voices are speaking up against it.

Designer Diane von Furstenberg, who is active in women's empowerment, doesn't agree with regulating the BMI of models. Don't get me wrong -- she wants models to be of a healthy weight, but she also states that "to calculate the girls' body mass ... is demeaning ... surely you are making them feel more like meat than ever -- even if it's little meat, if you know what I mean."

So what do you think? Should the fashion industry have specific regulations to meet, or should they simply use common sense and use models who are of a healthy weight? Should the responsibility fall back on the designers? After all, if they don't use sample sizes of zero and two, models won't have to fit into them. Or do you think the anoerexic look is just a trend and that we'll start seeing curvier women on the catwalks soon enough?

Reader Comments (Page 1 of 1)

How You Voted

    Threesome or topless?
    More than 3/4 of you think the CK campaign 'Threesome' campaign was more risque than Wrangler's topless models. Get the full story here.

    Inzemove and Fred & Farid

    Do these ads belong in the U.S.?
    StyleList readers were nearly evenly divided on this, with 52% thinking that they should run in the States, and 48% finding them inappropriate. Get the full story here.

    Inzemove and Fred & Farid

    Curly or Straight?
    While 30% of you think she's so beautiful that her hair doesn't even matter, 49% of you prefer her curls. Get the full story here.

    Kevin Winter, Getty Images | Jon Furniss, WireImage

    Offensive or artistic?
    Just over 50% of StyleList readers said they weren't offended by this shirt, but didn't know if it was totally appropriate to wear in public. Unfortunately, that wasn't the opinion in Dubai. Get the full story here.

    Photo: eBay

    ebay

    Strapless dresses on 13-year-olds
    StyleList readers think strapless dresses should be saved for older girls -- 41% of you think the look is too mature. Get the full story here.

    Getty Images

    Is Megan the new Angelina?
    Half of you think Megan needs to get her own identity and quit copying Angie, but more than a quarter said Jolie doesn't stand a chance against this Fox. Get the full story here.

    Getty Images

    Did Calvin Klein respond to public's outcry?
    The controversial "threesome" billboard in Soho has been replaced with this one, but 51% of you believe it was just to keep people talking about the brand, not because CK caved. Get the full story here.

    Rachel Been, AOL

    Calvin Klein's Racy Ad
    Is it art or practically pornography? About 40% of StyleList readers found this billboard obscene. Get the full story.

    Maggie Coughlan, AOL

    Palin's Pedi
    Do you think Sarah Palin's funky pedicure was appropriate? If so, you're in good company -- 68% of you said it was fun and fabulous. Get the full story.

    Getty Images

    Bright, Light, or Dark as Night?
    How do you like your toenails painted? Over half of StyleList readers prefer their piggies with bright, perky polish. Get the full story.

    Getty Images

StyleList Fashion Blog bloggers (30 days)

#BloggerPostsCmts
1Bee-Shyuan Chang580
2Maureen Dempsey390
3Amber Stolec260
4Kristen Seymour240
5Jessica B. Matlin230
6Marissa Gold210
7Courtney Dunlop130
8Ben Widdicombe120
9Sarah Cristobal60
10Katie Hintz40