Skip to Content

Passion for fashion? Visit the new StyleList!

How skinny is too skinny for TV?

Filed under: Style in the News, Celebrities with Style, Celebrity Fashion Mistakes



Here's a quick answer to that question. If you're on the cover of US Weekly, with the headline "TOO THIN FOR TV" across your chest? Then you absolutely are too thin.

Are Jessica Stroup and Shenae Grimes too thin?

(click thumbnails to view gallery)

  • Jessica Stroup of 90210
  • Shenae Grimes of 90210
  • Jessica Stroup of 90210
  • Shenae Grimes of 90210
  • Jessica Stroup of 90201


Shenae Grimes and Jessica Stroup, stars of the new 90210, are at the center of the latest "are they anorexic?!" tabloid frenzy. Cripes, sometimes it seems like everyone in Hollywood is either rumored to be pregnant or about to faint dead away from hunger.

We think it's totally unfair that young women are under so much pressure to be super slender, but the minute they cross some imaginary line those same girls are attacked by the media. Plus, lots of women really are naturally slim.

On the other hand, just look at these two. The US Weekly expert estimates that the 5' 3" Shenae weighs 90 pounds. Jessica, much taller at 5'8", is estimated to be only 100 pounds! That's unhealthy, whether it's "natural" or not.

And if you track their behavior -- they're always together, skipping meals and smoking during breaks, plus wearing clothes that show off their ribs and pointy backbones -- we have the latest incarnation of "Lindsay and Nicole, the Terrifying Rachel Zoe Years." They're the new Lollipop Twins.

Sooner or later, one of these size 00 starlets is going to drop dead from malnutrition. Is that what it's going to take for us to stop glorifying this starvation aesthetic?

In the gallery, you may judge for yourself if the girls look like they've crossed the line from "I don't eat dessert" to "I don't eat." We see a lot of ropey tendons, sharp clavicles and thighs the same size as their arms.

How You Voted

    Curly or Straight?
    While 30% of you think she's so beautiful that her hair doesn't even matter, 49% of you prefer her curls. Get the full story here.

    Kevin Winter, Getty Images | Jon Furniss, WireImage

    Offensive or artistic?
    Just over 50% of StyleList readers said they weren't offended by this shirt, but didn't know if it was totally appropriate to wear in public. Unfortunately, that wasn't the opinion in Dubai. Get the full story here.

    Photo: eBay

    ebay

    Strapless dresses on 13-year-olds
    StyleList readers think strapless dresses should be saved for older girls -- 41% of you think the look is too mature. Get the full story here.

    Getty Images

    Is Megan the new Angelina?
    Half of you think Megan needs to get her own identity and quit copying Angie, but more than a quarter said Jolie doesn't stand a chance against this Fox. Get the full story here.

    Getty Images

    Did Calvin Klein respond to public's outcry?
    The controversial "threesome" billboard in Soho has been replaced with this one, but 51% of you believe it was just to keep people talking about the brand, not because CK caved. Get the full story here.

    Rachel Been, AOL

    Calvin Klein's Racy Ad
    Is it art or practically pornography? About 40% of StyleList readers found this billboard obscene. Get the full story.

    Maggie Coughlan, AOL

    Palin's Pedi
    Do you think Sarah Palin's funky pedicure was appropriate? If so, you're in good company -- 68% of you said it was fun and fabulous. Get the full story.

    Getty Images

    Bright, Light, or Dark as Night?
    How do you like your toenails painted? Over half of StyleList readers prefer their piggies with bright, perky polish. Get the full story.

    Getty Images

    Nipple cream as lip balm?
    StyleList readers are willing to try anything! 80% of you either love the idea or, at the very least, think it's worth a try. Get the full story.

    notsogoodphotography on flickr

    Skip the skinny jeans
    Skinny jeans might be bad for you, but more than 50 percent of you never wore them anyway! Get the full story.

    Getty Images

Featured Galleries

StyleList Fashion Blog bloggers (30 days)

#BloggerPostsCmts
1Bee-Shyuan Chang540
2Maureen Dempsey420
3Kristen Seymour310
4Marissa Gold220
5Amber Stolec200
6Jessica B. Matlin190
7Courtney Dunlop150
8Ben Widdicombe120
9Sarah Cristobal80
10Melissa Foss40